---
title: Et tu, Brute?
description: You can learn a lot about a large-cap value product just by looking at the average market cap of the portfolio. While the category may be called large-cap value, there is an inherent conflict in trying to be both large-cap and value. Few of the largest stocks are cheap, and the cheapest stocks mostly fall toward the smaller end of the large-cap universe. So, if a large-cap value product has an average market cap over $50 or $100 billion, it is likely compromising value for the sake of market cap.
image: https://blog.lyricalam.com/hubfs/Cover%20D%20%C2%B7%20Painting%2c%20full%20bleed@2x%20(3).png
---

[![Lyricalam](https://blog.lyricalam.com/hs-fs/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Lyricalam_March2023/images/header-logo.png?width=1250&height=587&name=header-logo.png "Lyricalam")](https://lyricalam.com/)

- [Who We Are](https://lyricalam.com/who-we-are/) 
    - [Mission & Values](https://lyricalam.com/mission-values/)
    - [Team](https://lyricalam.com/team/)
- [Strategies](https://lyricalam.com/strategies/) 
    - [U.S. Value Equity Strategy](https://lyricalam.com/strategies/us-value-equity/)
    - [International Value Equity Strategy](https://lyricalam.com/strategies/international-value-equity/)
    - [Global Value Equity Strategy](https://lyricalam.com/strategies/global-value-equity/)
    - [Global Impact Value Equity Strategy](https://lyricalam.com/strategies/global-impact-value-equity/)
- [Investment Approach](https://lyricalam.com/investment-approach/)
- [Insights](https://blog.lyricalam.com/insights)
- [Notes & Disclaimers](https://lyricalam.com/notes-disclaimers/)
- [Contact](https://lyricalam.com/contact/)

- [Who We Are](https://lyricalam.com/who-we-are/) 
    - [Mission & Values](https://lyricalam.com/mission-values/)
    - [Team](https://lyricalam.com/team/)
- [Strategies](https://lyricalam.com/strategies/) 
    - [U.S. Value Equity Strategy](https://lyricalam.com/strategies/us-value-equity/)
    - [International Value Equity Strategy](https://lyricalam.com/strategies/international-value-equity/)
    - [Global Value Equity Strategy](https://lyricalam.com/strategies/global-value-equity/)
    - [Global Impact Value Equity Strategy](https://lyricalam.com/strategies/global-impact-value-equity/)
- [Investment Approach](https://lyricalam.com/investment-approach/)
- [Insights](https://blog.lyricalam.com/insights)
- [Notes & Disclaimers](https://lyricalam.com/notes-disclaimers/)
- [Contact](https://lyricalam.com/contact/)

## Et tu, Brute?

[![Download PDF](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/21666642/f8c074c3-6c57-4274-bf38-204ba82f16db.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/21666642/f8c074c3-6c57-4274-bf38-204ba82f16db)

Published On, **November 20, 2026**

 

“Et tu, Brute?” is the famous Latin phrase spoken by Julius Caesar at the moment of his assassination in Shakespeare’s play about the Roman dictator. Today, the phrase expresses the shock of an unexpected betrayal, and it comes to mind when we observe what has happened to the Large-Cap Value category.

Since the start of 2023, the Magnificent Seven have dominated the performance of the S&P 500 and their index weights have dramatically increased. These stocks now account for 33.2% of the index, and all seven are effectively technology stocks, creating significant concentration risk in passive S&P 500 exposure.

Given such S&P 500 concentration, differentiated active management has become an important source of portfolio diversification. Yet, differentiated portfolios have become harder to find. It is not surprising that Large-Cap Growth and Large-Cap Core funds commonly own several of these mega-cap growth stocks. What is surprising is how many Large-Cap Value funds own these stocks, too. Our examination of the 20 largest Large-Cap Value mutual funds reveals that every single one owns at least two of the Magnificent Seven.

At Lyrical, we continue to practice a disciplined, bottom-up approach to fundamental value investing. The Magnificent Seven stocks have not met our criteria for value and have never been part of our portfolio. Our holdings reflect a distinctly different large-cap opportunity set, as evidenced by our active share of 98.5% relative to the S&P 500 and limited overlap with other managers. Our uncommon holdings have provided an important source of diversification without “di-worse-ification.” Despite not owning any of the Magnificent Seven, our returns have mostly kept pace with the S&P 500 since 2023 when the Magnificent Seven performance run began.

For investors concerned about overlapping exposure to the Magnificent Seven, Lyrical offers a differentiated approach to large-cap equity investing. 

THE MAGNIFICENT SEVEN

The Magnificent Seven is the popular nickname for the seven mega-cap growth stocks that have dominated the returns of the S&P 500 since 2023. Specifically, the seven stocks are: Apple, NVIDIA, Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon, Meta and Tesla. These seven stocks now account for 33.2% of the S&P 500 weight, making the index far more concentrated than at any other time in recent history.

![Screenshot 2026-11-19 at 1.16.53 PM](https://blog.lyricalam.com/hs-fs/hubfs/AAA_Marketing_Material/Blog%20Posts/Et%20Tu,%20Brute/Screenshot%202026-11-19%20at%201.16.53%20PM.png?width=2046&height=1270&name=Screenshot%202026-11-19%20at%201.16.53%20PM.png)

It is not just how much weight is allocated to so few stocks, but also how they all are connected to the same sector. All the Magnificent Seven are essentially tech stocks, even as their official sector definition might say otherwise. Amazon is classified in Consumer Discretionary, but most of its profits come from AWS. Google and Meta were in the Technology sector until 2018 when S&P moved them into the redefined Communication Services sector. Finally, Tesla, with a forward P/E over 200x, is clearly perceived as a tech stock, not an automotive OEM.

MAGNIFICENT BUT NOT CHEAP

The Magnificent Seven are big companies, and they also come with big price tags. The chart below shows the forward P/E ratios for the seven. The priciest stock is Tesla at over 200x forward earnings. Apple is the next most expensive at 37.8x. Three more have P/Es in the 20s, and Nvidia and Meta have P/Es in the 17s.

These are the valuations you would expect to see in a Growth or Core portfolio, not a Value one.

![Screenshot 2026-11-19 at 4.03.40 PM](https://blog.lyricalam.com/hs-fs/hubfs/AAA_Marketing_Material/Blog%20Posts/Et%20Tu,%20Brute/Screenshot%202026-11-19%20at%204.03.40%20PM.png?width=980&height=510&name=Screenshot%202026-11-19%20at%204.03.40%20PM.png)

VALUE FUNDS HOP ON THE BANDWAGON

Given the valuations of the Magnificent Seven, investors might reasonably expect to avoid these stocks when investing in the Large-Cap Value category. However, a thorough examination of the largest mutual funds in the category shows that is not the case.

Presented in the table below are the Magnificent Seven holdings of the 20 largest Large-Cap Value mutual funds. These funds range in size from $120 billion down to $7.5 billion and collectively manage $832 billion.

Every fund on this top 20 list owns multiple Magnificent Seven stocks, with an average allocation of 12.9%. While none of the 20 own Tesla, which has the highest P/E of the Magnificent Seven, 14 own Apple which has the next highest P/E at 37.8x, and 19 own Microsoft, which is the third priciest at 25.3x.

The takeaway is that one cannot blindly rely on Large-Cap Value funds to diversify Magnificent Seven exposure. These are just the top 20, but others may also contain considerably more overlapping exposure than one would expect.

![Screenshot 2026-11-19 at 6.44.02 PM](https://blog.lyricalam.com/hs-fs/hubfs/AAA_Marketing_Material/Blog%20Posts/Et%20Tu,%20Brute/Screenshot%202026-11-19%20at%206.44.02%20PM.png?width=2174&height=1908&name=Screenshot%202026-11-19%20at%206.44.02%20PM.png)

DIVERSIFICATION, NOT “DI-WORSE-IFICATION”

Diversification is considered to be the only “free lunch” in finance, meaning it is the only known way to reduce risk without reducing return. With the high concentration of the S&P 500 today, the importance of portfolio diversification has only increased. Unfortunately, diversification has also become harder to find, with Magnificent Seven ownership rife among Large-Cap Growth, Core and even Value funds.

At Lyrical, we follow our disciplined VQA process wherever it leads us. We sift through the cheapest large-cap stocks to find those with the most attractive quality and growth. The Magnificent Seven have never met our investment criteria, and so we have never owned them.

Despite never owning them, our returns have mostly kept pace with the S&P 500 since the Magnificent Seven performance run began in 2023. That performance is especially noteworthy given that only 20% of S&P 500 constituents outperformed over that period. Furthermore, we achieved these returns while maintaining our value discipline. Over our firm history, the S&P 500 forward P/E has traded at a 50% premium to our portfolio on average, and recently that premium has been even higher.

Lyrical has the process, product and people to bring something beneficial and different to your portfolio. Our strategy of finding the “gems amid the junk” leads to an uncommon combination of value and growth, and a set of holdings not typically found in other funds. 

---

### Contact Us to Learn More

 

 

<iframe style="display: none; margin: 0px auto;" xml="lang" name="target_iframe_7cd7e6c1-eb5b-4099-a2c0-71da550b4d88_3688" width="560" height="315"></iframe>

---

 

IMPORTANT NOTES:

ALL DATA IS AS OF OCTOBER 31, 2026.  THIS DOCUMENT MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED OR REDISTRIBUTED WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF LYRICAL ASSET MANAGEMENT (LAM).THIS IS NOT AN OFFERING OR THE SOLICITATION OF AN OFFER TO INVEST IN LYRICAL'S U.S. STRATEGIES. ANY SUCH OFFERING CAN ONLY BE MADE FOLLOWING A ONE-ON-ONE PRESENTATION, AND ONLY TO QUALIFIED INVESTORS IN THOSE JURISDICTIONS WHERE PERMITTED BY LAW.

THERE IS NO GUARANTEE THAT THE INVESTMENT OBJECTIVE OF THE STRATEGY WILL BE ACHIEVED. RISKS OF AN INVESTMENT IN THIS STRATEGY INCLUDE, BUT ARE NOT LIMITED TO, THE RISKS OF INVESTING IN EQUITY SECURITIES GENERALLY, AND IN A VALUE INVESTING APPROACH. PLEASE SEE WWW.LYRICALAM.COM/NOTES FOR A DISCUSSION OF CERTAIN MATERIAL RISKS OF AN INVESTMENT IN LYRICAL’S STRATEGIES.

PAST PERFORMANCE IS NOT NECESSARILY INDICATIVE OF FUTURE RESULTS. 

![Screenshot 2026-11-19 at 1.20.13 PM](https://blog.lyricalam.com/hs-fs/hubfs/AAA_Marketing_Material/Blog%20Posts/Et%20Tu,%20Brute/Screenshot%202026-11-19%20at%201.20.13%20PM.png?width=2034&height=504&name=Screenshot%202026-11-19%20at%201.20.13%20PM.png)

 

THE S&P 500® IS WIDELY REGARDED AS THE BEST SINGLE GAUGE OF LARGE-CAP U.S. EQUITIES. THE INDEX INCLUDES 500 LEADING COMPANIES AND COVERS APPROXIMATELY 80% OF AVAILABLE MARKET CAPITALIZATION.

THE S&P 500® EQUAL WEIGHT INDEX (EWI) IS THE EQUAL-WEIGHT VERSION OF THE WIDELY-USED S&P 500. THE INDEX INCLUDES THE SAME CONSTITUENTS AS THE CAPITALIZATION WEIGHTED S&P 500, BUT EACH COMPANY IN THE S&P 500 EWI IS ALLOCATED A FIXED WEIGHT - OR 0.2% OF THE INDEX TOTAL AT EACH QUARTERLY REBALANCE.

THE S&P 500® VALUE INDEX MEASURES THE PERFORMANCE OF THE LARGE-CAP VALUE SEGMENT OF THE U.S. EQUITY UNIVERSE. IT INCLUDES THOSE S&P 500 COMPANIES WITH LOWER PRICE-TO-BOOK RATIOS AND LOWER EXPECTED GROWTH VALUES. THE S&P 500 VALUE INDEX IS CONSTRUCTED TO PROVIDE A COMPREHENSIVE AND UNBIASED BAROMETER OF THE LARGE-CAP VALUE SEGMENT. THE INDEX IS COMPLETELY RECONSTITUTED ANNUALLY TO ENSURE NEW AND GROWING EQUITIES ARE INCLUDED AND THAT THE REPRESENTED COMPANIES CONTINUE TO REFLECT VALUE CHARACTERISTICS.

Tagged [General Insights](https://blog.lyricalam.com/insights/tag/general-insights)

- [Who We Are](https://lyricalam.com/who-we-are/)
- [Investment Approach](https://lyricalam.com/investment-approach/)
- [Strategies](https://lyricalam.com/strategies/)
- [Team](https://lyricalam.com/team/)
- [Insights](https://blog.lyricalam.com/insights)
- [Notes & Disclaimers](https://lyricalam.com/notes-disclaimers/)
- [Sustainability-Related Disclosures](https://lyricalam.com/sustainability-related-disclosures/)
- [Contact](https://lyricalam.com/contact/)

250 West 55th Street,  
Floor 37  
New York, NY 10019

[(212) 415-6600](tel:2124156600)  
[info@lyricalam.com](mailto:info@lyricalam.com)

<https://www.linkedin.com/company/lyrical-asset-management/>

[![Lyricalam](https://blog.lyricalam.com/hs-fs/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Lyricalam_March2023/images/footer-logo.png?width=1024&height=587&name=footer-logo.png "Lyricalam")](https://lyricalam.com/)

Copyright © 2026 Lyrical Asset Management LP. All rights reserved.

[Customer Relationship Summary](https://lyricalam.com/customer-relationship-summary) | [Privacy Policy](https://blog.lyricalam.com/hubfs/Website/Privacy_Policy.pdf) | [Form ADV, Part 2](https://lyricalam.com/form-adv-part-2)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Lyrical Investment Team",
    "url" : "https://blog.lyricalam.com/insights/author/lyrical-investment-team"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-20T19:28:06.541Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-20T19:28:06.000Z",
  "headline" : "Et tu, Brute?",
  "image" : [ "https://blog.lyricalam.com/hubfs/Cover%20D%20%C2%B7%20Painting%2c%20full%20bleed@2x%20(3).png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://blog.lyricalam.com/insights/et-tu-brute",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://blog.lyricalam.com/hubfs/Lyrical-AM-logo.png"
    },
    "name" : "Lyrical Asset Management"
  }
}
```